


Original author: CZ, Founder of Binance
Original source: Talking Tokens (hosted by Jacquelyn Melinek)
Original compilation: Jiahuan, ChainCatcher
After Binance suffered a hack of approximately $6.3 billion, CZ sat down with Talking Tokens to recount his reaction upon learning of the breach, and to discuss Binance's crisis response, user fund flows, AI security risks, and the possibility of industry-wide collective defense.
CZ said he no longer directly manages Binance, so after the incident his main role was to communicate with the community. He believes that both Binance and the broader crypto industry have not invested enough in security, and that as AI capabilities grow, attacks may continue to accelerate. The industry needs to work with AI companies and push for the creation of a security alliance.
a. Learning about the hack while getting ready for bed: CZ said it was nearly midnight in the UAE, and he learned the news from the Binance team and on X at almost the same time. Since he no longer directly manages Binance, he focused mainly on community sentiment and getting the information he had out as quickly as possible.
b. Acknowledging insufficient security investment: CZ believes neither Binance nor the crypto industry as a whole has invested enough in security. Companies tend to let their guard down gradually after long periods without a security incident, and attacks often expose problems that had been overlooked.
c. AI is accelerating attacks, but will also be used for defense: CZ believes malicious actors have already begun leveraging AI, while the industry has not yet gained adequate AI defense capabilities in time. More security problems may surface in the short term, but over the long run, AI is expected to help make crypto platforms and software safer.
d. Pushing for an industry security alliance: CZ said the industry has already discussed forming a security alliance that would let participants share best practices, conduct cross-audits, and help quickly freeze funds after incidents. He hopes to help drive this mechanism, though the specific form has yet to be determined.
e. Seeking government assistance: Asked whether he had communicated with Trump or Washington, CZ said he had not contacted them about this incident, but hoped that governments capable of communicating with North Korea — such as the U.S. and China — would offer help.
f. On market and fund flows: CZ believes Binance's rapid commitment to cover losses eased concerns about contagion. He also said only about 6% to 10% of outflow funds went to other centralized exchanges, though the interview did not specify the source of that figure.
g. Advice for ordinary users: CZ recommends that users familiarize themselves with different asset custody tools, learn how to protect their assets, and stay informed about security news. He believes both self-custody and platform custody carry their own risks that need to be managed.
Host: Last Thursday, Binance suffered a hack of approximately $6.3 billion. The FBI attributed the attack to North Korea's TraderTraitor hacking group. Before we discuss these issues, I'd like to go back to last Thursday: how did you learn the news, and what were you doing at the time? Had you ever considered that something like this could happen?
CZ: It was around midnight in the UAE, and I was getting ready for bed while scrolling through X. The team told me Binance was under attack. At roughly the same time, I saw the news on X as well, but wasn't sure if it was real. That news woke me up pretty fast — honestly, I was a bit shocked.
But when you run a crypto exchange, you always know deep down that security incidents can happen at any time — there's no way to rule it out 100%. The key is to deal with it as quickly as possible once it happens. I think response speed and protecting users are both critical. Typically in these situations, you have to handle two tracks simultaneously: one is containing and fixing the problem, first and foremost preventing the attack from spreading further; the other is making sure users don't panic and preventing broader market panic.
I no longer manage Binance, so I wasn't directly involved in the company's internal handling. But I have a lot of followers on X and some influence in the crypto industry. So I focused more on community sentiment, trying to relay what I knew to the community quickly and transparently.
Host: Many people feel that Binance and your response this time were very swift. In past hacks or similar incidents in the industry, we haven't necessarily seen this kind of reaction. After going through this attack, what is your biggest takeaway?
CZ: Looking back over the past few days, I think there are certainly many areas for improvement, and many problems that could have been prevented. All hacks are preventable, so there's a lot of room for improvement. Companies tend to become complacent over time: security incidents don't happen — until they suddenly do. But before that, there were often things that had been overlooked. With enough effort and attention, security incidents can be prevented. There are many lessons worth learning from this one.
Host: The FBI said this attack came from state-sponsored North Korean hackers. When companies consider North Korean hackers, are they dealing with a corporate security issue, or has it become a national security issue — even a global security issue?
CZ: I think it's all three, because there are no clear boundaries between these levels. For a company, this is of course a major problem. And it's not just Binance — every crypto company, every crypto platform and crypto protocol has to face this. The same is true for the traditional financial system; North Korean hackers attack banks too, and they've been known for that in the past.
What happens in the crypto industry now also affects the global economy. The global financial system is increasingly intertwined with the crypto industry — there are tokenized stocks, RWAs, and stablecoins pegged to government short-term treasuries, all interconnected. So when a problem of this scale occurs in crypto, it also affects the real economy in other sectors.
You can't simply say this is one company's problem or one specific industry's problem. It affects companies, the industry, and the global financial system. Given the scale of impact, it certainly involves national security as well.
Host: More and more capital is moving on-chain, and more people and institutions want to enter this space, but hackers are also looking for opportunities. Banks get attacked too, but is the crypto industry really ready for mass adoption right now?
CZ: I think this is a chicken-and-egg problem. Without adoption, there may not be enough capital to invest in technology, so demand and supply need to grow together. You can't wait until technology is 100% mature before using it — and there's no such thing as 100% maturity anyway; technology is always improving.
AI is developing very fast and bringing many security challenges. In the past, we might see an attack once a month, or only every so often; now there have been stretches where we see attacks every week — yesterday alone there were four different attacks. As AI capabilities grow stronger, the pace of attacks will accelerate too.
At the same time, we must use AI more for defense. The only way to fight a monster is, in a sense, to become the monster — so we really do need AI capabilities for defense. There's no perfect moment when we can say technology has matured; it's always evolving.
The reverse is also true: if we can't control these security incidents and they keep happening with no end in sight, adoption will slow down, and that affects the entire industry. But any new technology goes through an adaptation period, and the process can be painful. I believe positive forces will ultimately prevail, and things should improve over time. I don't know where the bottom or turning point is — we may see more problems before things get better overall, but hopefully we'll get there soon.
Host: On October 31, President Trump said he didn't yet know whether the attack came from North Korea, but that if it did, he would communicate with North Korea about it. Now that the FBI has made its attribution, what are your thoughts? What action would you like to see from Washington? Have you spoken with President Trump?
CZ: I have not communicated with President Trump or anyone in Washington about this incident. Of course we would welcome their help — myself, Binance, and the entire crypto industry would all welcome assistance from the U.S. government. If anyone can communicate with North Korea, it's probably only one or two governments, such as the U.S. and China. So any help we can get, we welcome.
In one video clip I saw, President Trump appeared to be at a gathering, someone casually asked him a question, and he answered. I don't think that should be taken too formally — it wasn't a statement issued through official procedures. That said, I know President Trump will try to solve problems. In any case, I haven't communicated with him, but we hope for help.
Host: There are some rather pessimistic views right now. Some mention "Black October," warning that banks and other large institutions are becoming targets of AI attacks. After the Binance hack, what advice would you give to others? How do you think they should rethink security?
CZ: For any crypto company, financial company, or any company with security needs — which is almost all companies — they must pay close attention to and use AI technology. Companies should also consider working with AI companies to use AI-based approaches to solve the security problems AI creates.
The early days of the internet had similar situations. New viruses kept appearing, and antivirus software sold well as a result. Attack and defense have always happened simultaneously. Today, malicious actors are using AI to do harm. AI is developing very fast, with many open-source models and different models in different countries. Even with closed-source models, people can find ways to trick them into being used for attacks. So we must use AI for defense at scale.
Frankly, I think the AI industry and AI companies haven't yet figured out how to provide defense capabilities fast enough before attack capabilities emerge. We've had many discussions around this issue. I think it's a solvable problem and will eventually be solved, but the industry must work closely with these technology providers. There have already been some fairly in-depth discussions.
As an industry, we also need to tackle this together. There have been several discussions proposing some form of industry security alliance — letting everyone learn from each other's mistakes, share best practices, conduct cross-audits, and help quickly freeze funds when incidents occur. Given what's happened over the past few months, I think this alliance could come together relatively quickly. I don't know what form it will ultimately take, but I hope to play some role in helping make it happen.
Host: You mentioned earlier that the industry may be nearing the bottom of "Black October" or this worrying period, and hoping for an upward turn afterward. What developments in Binance, the crypto industry, and AI are you optimistic about going forward?
CZ: In the medium to long term, I firmly believe AI will make the crypto industry, platforms, and software safer. AI can uncover some very hidden problems. Suffering attacks now is indeed painful, but it also gives us a chance to build defenses. Overall, it will make systems safer, even though the process is quite painful.
AI is also accelerating development in software and other areas — mainly software for now — which will speed up technological progress. There's even industry discussion that AI may find vulnerabilities in blockchain software before quantum computing breaks encryption. As problems are exposed, the industry must keep evolving and growing stronger.
Beyond that, AI will facilitate transactions at speeds far beyond anything we've seen before, and the only financial technology capable of supporting that speed is blockchain. So I'm very optimistic about the future, despite all the worry over the past few days. But given the circumstances, I think Binance handled it relatively well — Binance covered all the losses, and users didn't lose out.
Host: Are you also bullish on the market's future?
CZ: I don't want to predict prices, and this isn't financial advice. There's a lot of discussion on X that the market needs to take a major hit to bottom out, and once it bottoms, the only way is up. I'm not saying the market will rise tomorrow — that's very hard to predict — but I am indeed very bullish on the future.
Host: The market's reaction to this attack seems relatively muted. Prices dipped slightly, but the change wasn't as dramatic as one might expect.
CZ: I think this is exactly where communication matters so much. Binance and I quickly came out and said: user funds were not affected — user funds are safe. It's a simple statement, but it helped stop a chain reaction. People understood that this wouldn't be like some other platform or lending protocol bankruptcies where users bear the losses, and there wouldn't be second- or third-round effects.
First, that calmed people down. Second, you need enough credibility for people to believe what you say. A lot of things are obvious on-chain. Looking back at some of the collapses in 2022, those institutions borrowed from elsewhere and withdrew funds from different platforms — people could see it all.
But in this case, people know Binance has the financial strength to cover the losses. Binance has the SAFU fund, a futures insurance fund, and a very strong balance sheet. The rapid response, along with the ability to take responsibility, cover user losses, and protect users, calmed people down.
Interestingly, when the incident happened on Thursday, the crypto market's decline was actually smaller than the tech stock market's — almost unheard of. Normally when stocks fall, crypto falls more, because people want to hold cash and sell crypto assets. But that day, despite such a major attack on the crypto industry, the market decline was actually smaller. So I think everyone stayed calm, and the trust built up over the years is quite solid — I'm proud of that.
Host: Earlier today, Binance announced that since the attack, it had seen deposits exceed withdrawals in a single hour for the first time. That seems to reflect the trust issue you just talked about.
CZ: After incidents like this, withdrawals are normal. Platforms pause withdrawals, some large institutions have policies requiring them to move funds out, and some retail users follow suit. But after withdrawing, the question is: where is my money safer?
At Binance, user funds weren't lost in this incident because Binance covered the losses. The incident happened at Binance, which is of course frightening, but where should the funds go next? Recently, several hardware wallets have also had security incidents — one involving a supply chain attack, another involving mnemonic phrase generation.
In those cases, users may have done nothing wrong. They followed standard procedures, bought a hardware wallet, or generated their own mnemonic phrase, but years later they could still lose funds — through no fault of their own, with no one to cover the losses. Whereas if funds are on Binance, Binance covers the loss this time.
Users could also choose smaller platforms. They aren't the primary targets and may not be hit in the first wave. But now that Binance has been attacked and has fixed the problem, the next wave of attacks may turn to smaller platforms. In my view, Binance is safer now.
Some people who withdraw find they need to back up their mnemonic phrase. Some say less than 10% of outflow funds — about 6% to 10% — went to other centralized exchanges, meaning most of the funds may have been moved to users' own self-custody wallets. But with self-custody wallets, you need to back up your mnemonic phrase yourself and make sure it isn't damaged or lost. Many people lose funds in self-custody — and not even because of hackers.
So after comparing, people may choose to put their funds back on Binance. I just saw a post saying that in less than 24 hours, Binance saw net inflows within a single hour. I think that reflects the platform's strength and user trust. Fund flows will certainly fluctuate in the coming weeks or months, but if the market enters a bull run, we may see more deposits.
Host: Binance has published many announcements, and you've posted quite a few messages yourself. Finally, is there anything you haven't posted on social media but want people to know?
CZ: Technology is developing very fast, especially AI. It's growing so quickly that this exponential growth is hard for people to truly grasp. I think neither Binance nor the industry as a whole has invested enough in security. Frankly, many AI security tools are not yet available to the industry.
I hope everyone invests more in these areas — adding security engineers, using more AI tools, and working closely with AI security service providers. These are all critical.
For ordinary users, I recommend familiarizing yourself with different tools, learning how to protect your assets, and staying on top of the news. I know it may feel right now like nowhere is absolutely safe, but I believe things will gradually improve. During this turbulent period, we must stay vigilant and take protection seriously.